Costs of administering a THC tax?

Which would cost more to administer, a THC tax or a price-based tax?

It’s not clear. With standard seed-to-sale tracking, which I assume North Carolina will require, the taxpayer takes the THC amount from the certificate of analysis and reports it on a return, much as North Carolina beer wholesalers report gallons. Tax authorities get a clear, immediate audit trail.

A price-based tax leaves room to maneuver. How much of a shareholder discount is really a disguised dividend meant to avoid tax? How much of an employee discount is compensation that avoids income and FICA taxes? And if we tax upstream of retail and allow vertical integration, every internal transfer needs a price, and we’re in the soup.

Taxpayers may shop for labs that understate THC to cut their taxes, but they also have a countervailing incentive to overstate it to attract THC-seeking customers. Either way, the state should do random retesting, as it already does to verify gasoline sellers’ octane claims.

Leave a Reply